I chose to do my text set on the Holocaust, specifically focusing on children during the Holocaust. I thought it was important to focus on children since students would be able to relate to the thinking of individuals similar in age, comparing and contrasting their lives to the lives that we are reading about. I’m planning this text set for sixth grade. The reason I chose this age group is because I feel at this age they are able to understand that there is good and bad in the world. Reading these books wouldn’t make them think badly about the world. I know that even younger elementary are able to grasp the fact that there is bad in the world. The concept of losing your best friend because of hatred is hard to stomach at any age and I feel that older elementary would be able to critically read it and not let the concept weigh them down to much.
Another reason why it is important to learn about the Holocaust is so history doesn’t repeat itself. If a student can see how far the concept of thinking you are better than someone else can go; they might think twice about what they say and how they act. Also by giving students examples of kids being courageous and standing up for what they believe shows that they should always stand up for something they believe in. I would use the quote “always stand up for what you believe in even if it means standing alone.” If it wasn’t for the many people who hid
Jews and others being deported thousands more people would have died in the war.
The Holocaust fits into my philosophy because I feel that students need to experience as many things to be able to make proper judgments about life and the world around them. There is no way I would want to make a play Holocaust and have them have a character and live it out to see whether they would die or not. An easier way to have the same effect would be through reading books. By finding an engaging text about the Holocaust, something that is thought provoking, would allow the students to be able to experience it without having to be in danger in that type of situation.
When a teacher is selecting literature there is a few things to keep in mind. Making sure the book is age appropriate for the students is very important. As the teacher you don’t want to get a book that will go over everyone heads. Also as a teacher you want to make sure the book doesn’t have explicit content that the students wouldn’t handle maturely. As with my topic you have to make sure the students know that this is a deep topic to be studying and that they have to act in a mature manner. As stated in chapter 3, a high quality book seems to speak to you as your read it. To go along with this a teacher wants to pick books that are engaging to the reader and make them not want to put it down. If a teacher picks a book that is dull the reader may not get out what is meant to get from the book. A teacher also needs to make sure that the reported facts being presented are true. This is pertinent in my text set since most of the books are fiction though mostly based on a true story. As the teacher I need to make sure the students understand what is the truth and what is not. This topic would fit into the curriculum because it is gives the students a perspective they can relate to about a historic event. It also gives many different styles of writing that as a class we would analyze which ones we enjoyed more than others. This would allow the students to look more in depth about how it was being written instead of just the content. Another way it would fit would be discussing the different literary elements and how they develop in each of the different books.
To start off this unit about children of the Holocaust I would have the students make a KWL chart that they will keep in their Children of the Holocaust binder. I’m having them use a binder to be able to keep all their papers together, since we will be doing both small and large group readings. In each binder there will be loose paper where the students will keep their journal entries, responses, and predictions. It is just a helpful way to keep the students organized. To start it off I would have the students look up what the word Holocaust means and write it in their journals. Then we would have a little discussion as to what the word means and any prior knowledge to what happened during World War II.
Before we would start the whole group reading book (Number the Stars) I would make sure that the students had time to do some background research. I would prepare a fact sheet for each student that would be missing information that the students would need to find (hidden around the room, would be the words that they would need to fill in the blanks. A fun scavenger hut to make them interested in what the answers might be). After finding the answers around the room they would discuss with the table groups the astonishing facts that they find. After several minutes I would open it up to a full class discussion about what the students thought about the facts (which include why it occurred, what Hitler was, who was targeted, the different powers (Axis and Allied), how many died, where Jews were sent, etc). on one of the Bulletin boards I would title it Timeline of World War II. Then I would have the years of the war placed along the line with enough space to be able to pin note cards (which would be cut in half). We would add the different events from the readings we do.
I would use Number the Stars as a whole group read. We read this as a class at the same pace. Some times I would read aloud while others times the students would read silently to themselves. There would be dead lines for each set of pages. We would read this book all the way through before I split them up into their small groups. Throughout the book I would have the students do little projects relevant to what is going on in the text. I would have them keep a character list going with descriptions of who everyone was. I would have them make a concept map for traits of Annemarie. Included in the Holocaust binder would be a map of the area with the important towns included. For each story we read we will be able to use the map to know locations, and figure out distances from where they travel. I would either have them map out the journeys in different colors or have a different map for each book. There are several books that take place in Denmark it would be interesting to compare those books and the different paths they take. I would also do sketch to stretch for the different chapters in the book to be able to have them around the room. I would also make a set of note cards with important events that occurred in the book for each table set. I would then have the students put the events in order without talking with their group (like the Zoom activity). The big point I would be trying to get across is that there is no age limit for being courageous. Which is shown through the characters in the book being brave and courageous. When discussing the word courageous I would have the students fill out a concept map of what comes to mind when they think of the word. The concept map would be used as a jumping off point for the discussion. For this book I would have the individual students do a project, that they would chose from the list I provided. Also have the students form groups and act out an important part of the plot.
After finishing Number the Stars I would have the students pick one of the four groups they would like to be in. Before the students were allowed to pick the groups I would do a small explanation about what each group would be doing. I would make sure the sign up was random by drawing sticks and having them sign up on the board. While the small groups were occurring I would visit with each group to hear their discussions. Also I would ask questions to check for understanding. Each group would present their final project to the whole class.
The first group would read Hitler’s Canary. I would have discussion questions for the group to answer throughout the book and other small activities to do with each set of chapters they had to read. The project I would have them do would involve comparing and contrasting to Number the Stars. Since both the books take place in Denmark and are about families helping Jews escape the Nazi wrath. Apart of this project I would have them compare and contrast the main characters, setting, challenges they faced. Once they had their comparisons written out I would make a poster about the two books and the similarities and difference (pretty much a Venn diagram without the circles). This group will present the poster to the class and explain the differences.
The second group would read Anne Frank and The Story of Anne Frank. I would have them read The Diary of a Young Girl but I heard it wasn’t age appropriate. This group would also do a character map of Anne Frank including a timeline of events. The two books listed above are picture books so the students may need to do some more research to be able to do their final project. For this group’s final project I have them making a readers theatre for Anne Frank’s life. I would require a rough draft turned into me so I could check for accurate content since they will be presenting this to the class later. I feel a reader’s theatre would be a great way to show the happenings of the many Jewish families that went into hiding trying to escape the Nazi relocation.
The third group would read Don’t Talk to Me About the War and Is it Night or Day? The reason I paired these two together because it shows the aspect of the United States and what was going on here while the war was raging in Europe. Both books show a different perspective though (one of a boy who lived here all his life and the other of German Jew immigrant who arrived here all alone). I would have the students keep a detailed timeline and have them compare it to the events that are happening in Europe. These comparisons would be kept in their journals in their binders. I would have the students make a pro/con list as to why the United States should be involved in the war. I would have the students pick the climax of each book and act it out to the class. This will show the differences between the books.
The fourth group would read The Boy in the Striped Pajamas and Rose Blanche. The reason I paired these two books together is because it shows two children who run across a fence with people on the other side who need food. It shows book children doing what they can to provide food and make friends with those children behind the fence. The Boy in the Striped Pajamas would be the main focus of this group since it is a novel. I would have mini activities and response topics that would need to be addressed in their journals. Rose Blanche would just be a way for students to get another perspective. I would have them compare and contrast the settings and characters from both books. For the final project for the this group I would give them a list of options of what they could do (make a poster, readers theatre, character analysis, make a diagram of the setting, etc.). I feel this group should have a choice what to do because requiring a reader’s theatre may be hard for students to perform since the climax involves death in both books.
After the students finished their small groups I would make sure that we read the afterwards of the books as a class. I feel like they are tied up loose ends and explain what was true and what was fiction in the book. I would want the whole class to hear them all even if they didn’t read the book because it would add more to their knowledge base.
The other books in the set (The Year of Goodbyes, Willy & Max, The Harmonica, The Secret Seder, and World War II: an interactive History Adventure) are to be used as supporting books for the others in the set. Also to be used on an individual read so the students could further their knowledge about the topic. Depending on how things were going I might read some of these books to the class and have them write a response in their journals. At the end of this unit I would give the students enough time to blog about this experience, including talking about Number the Stars and then their small groups.
When I was selecting texts for the set, I chose books that added a different perspective or a different location to the image of the Holocaust. However there were some books that I chose because they helped support a similar concept that was going on in a different book. There weren’t that many books on the Holocaust in the Children’s section and I didn’t venture outside of their because I wanted to make sure the content was age appropriate for the students. I did find many books on Barnes and Noble online that would add the view of actually being in a concentration camp. In all the books that are in the set, only three briefly discuss what it is like to be on the other side of the fence (The Boy in the Stripped Pajamas, The Harmonica, and Rose Blanche). When actually doing this set I would make sure there were short novels and picture books that show the perspective of being in a concentration camp (including the number system and events that occurred). I am aware that it is hard to find books about survivors because who would want to write a book about the pain they suffered.
Bibliography
Rappaport, Doreen. The Secret Seder.
This a picture book about a family who stays in France after the Nazi’s invade and pretend to be Catholic. By staying in France while in control by the Nazi’s is a very dangerous thing to do. A Seder is a Jewish holiday. The mom wants them to skip it because it is too dangerous but the little boy promised his Grandpa when they fled that they would celebrate every holiday no matter what. The boy and his father make a secret trip into the woods to a barn far from town. That is where the secret Seder was being held. They go through the ritual of the ceremony. At the end you discover that most people there have faith that things will get better before the next Seder.
Johnston, Tony. The Harmonica.
This picture book is about a toy, a harmonica; the boy receives before the Nazi’s invade Poland. When there was dancing and laughing with his family. He used to play the Harmonica while his parents danced around the kitchen. When the invasion occurred the boy was spilt from his parents and sent to work in a concentration camp where he was worked to the bone. Sometimes at night he would get the harmonica out and just hold it and think of his parents. Then one brave night he played it in the crowded sleeping hall. Nights that followed he continued to play. The Nazi officer in charge heard of the tune he was playing and required him to play for him every night before sleep. In return for him playing the officer would give him more food. The playing of the tune gave other prisoners hope and remembrance of what life used to be like.
Lewis, Brenda Ralph. The Story of Anne Frank.
It is a level reading book about Anne Frank’s life. Starting with her life in Frankfurt and then moving to Amsterdam to escape Hitler and the Nazi’s. Keeps to the facts of the times and gives specific dates of when they occur coming straight from Anne’s diary. I really liked that this book stuck to the facts and really didn’t go into vulgar details about what happened. Though it did say what happened after they were captured and split apart. I think that it is an important part of history to know the bad things that happened in concentration camps.
Poole, Josephine. Anne Frank.
This is a picture book dictating the life of Anne Frank. The illustrations were amazing. It is the story of Anne Frank it starts when she was born to give some background. Then it jumps to when Hitler came into power and all the sacrifices that the Frank family had to make to be able to survive. In the end you find out that the only person of the 8 living in the annex to survive was Mr. Frank.
Littlesugar, Amy. Willy & Max: A Holocaust Story.
This picture book is about a friendship between two boys, one who was Jewish. It reminded me what it would have been like if Nazi’s could have seen others like children did and just become friends with them instead of killing them. The two boys become friends and meet most days to play somewhere. This is before the war had reached their town. They are spilt apart because of the war but the picture of the lady that willy’s dad sells Max is what binds them. After the war Willy moved to the U.S. and started a family. He was contacted many years later because someone found the picture of the lady and was trying to get it back to its owner.
Innocenti, Roberto. Rose Blanche.
This picture book is about a young girl Rose who lives in Germany. One day she sees a boy her age get taken away with others in a truck. Curious where they are taking him she follows them into the forest. What she discovers is a fence with children on the other side all wearing the same thing. They ask for food and she gives them what she has left. She brings them food every couple of days. Then one day the whole town was fleeing but Rose still makes the trip to the fence. It was fogging and when she gets there the fence is gone. Soldiers are fighting all around her she ends up getting caught in the crossfire. The illustrations added to the text. It was very courageous of rose to sacrifice her own meal to help those who were hungry.
Raum, Elizabeth. World War II An interactive History Adventure.
This short book about the war is very interactive. On some pages you are set with a choice to make, and at the bottom of the page it says that choices and what pages to turn to so that you can finish your journey. I read through it and ended up dying in a concentration camp because I took a risk. Though there are many different paths you can take. I thought it would be a fun book to include that puts the students in the situation where they have to make the decisions.
Toksvig, Sandi. Hitler’s Canary.
This novel takes place in Denmark and is similar to Number the Stars. It is about helping the Jewish population of Denmark across the sea to Sweden. Only in this story it is from a boy’s point of view. I would use this story as a paired set with Number the Stars. Addressing what it means to be brave and courageous.
Lowry, Lois. Number the Stars.
This novel is about the brave people of Denmark who helped their Jewish neighbors and friends across the sea to safe Sweden. This story is through the point of view of Annemarie and her task of helping her best friend escape the Nazi relocation. They travel to her Uncle who is a fisherman and helps transports Jews to Sweden. It shows how brave she had to be and how not knowing the whole truth can save your life. A good point to bring up about this book is that the Danish Resistance helped smuggle around seven thousand people across the sea to safety.
Boyne, John. The Boy in the Striped Pajamas.
This novel is about a boy named Bruno who moves from Berlin to some small town because his dad got a promotion to commandant for the Nazi army. One day Bruno goes on an adventure into the forest and finds a fence. On the other side of the fence is a boy name Shmuel. Bruno visits almost every day and the boys become really good friends. They play games through the fence and talk. Bruno usually brings food to share because Shmuel says he is always hungry. They become very good friends over the year. One day Shmuel’s dad goes missing so the boys set up a day where Bruno will come under the fence and help him look for his dad. Bruno loved being a detective. On that day Shmuel got him some pajamas and he crawls under the fence. It isn’t how Bruno had imagined it. They search for his father, but find no clues. Bruno is about to head home when a group of soldiers gather a bunch of people together to go on a march. They end up in a chamber and that is where it ends for both of them holding onto their best friends hand.
Levy, Debbie. The year of Goodbyes: A true story of friendship, family, and farewells.
This book is written in poem style based off a poem book owned by the author’s mother while she was growing up in Germany. The book is a story of a Jewish family who stay in Germany as long as they can until they are forced to leave. They find out later that the day after they boarded the boat to America Nazi’s raided the town of Hamburg, deporting all Jews living in the city. Many were taken to concentration camps or to ghetto. At both of these places many Jews died.
Adler, David. Don’t Talk to Me About the War. Published: 2008 fiction.
About a boy, named Tommy, in the United States, who wants nothing to do with the war, either talking or hearing about it. Though he walks to school with his friend Beth, and the war is the only thing she wants to talk about. It takes place before U.S. involvement in the war. It isn’t until a Jewish boy from school starts telling his story that Tommy finally starts to care about what is going on in the rest of the world.
Chapman, Fern Schumer. Is it Night or Day? Published: 2010 fiction.
This book is about a twelve-year old girl, Edith. Who is forced to leave Germany alone because her parents can’t get permission to leave. She is traveling to Chicago. Where she is forced to adjust with American calling her names, as she is trying to discover who she really is. This is based on a true the author’s mother, who was part of One Thousand Children project the United States did during World War II.